Chapter 1014 The ignored broadcast effect
“Mr. Chang, I think you shouldn’t be too anxious…”
Wu Wei, who was a little unable to hold himself tight, opened his mouth to comfort him:
“The transmission rate and transmission stability of wireless systems cannot be compared with wired systems, so the results are slightly worse... This should be normal, right?”
“That’s not right!”
However, Chang Haonan''s response was to shake his head decisively:
“The transmission rate of the wireless system is indeed not as good as the wired system, but our test has controlled the transmission method. The experimental group and the control group are both wireless transmission, so there should be no difference in the improvement rate.”
“As for stability…”
?He paused for a moment, raised his head and looked at Wu Wei with serious eyes:
“If we analyze it from this perspective, then for less stable transmission methods, the improvement brought by network coding technology should be more obvious.”
“In short, there is only an improvement of less than 5 times…there must be something wrong…”
…”
??Wu Wei wanted to express some objections to this description of "only five times", but seeing that Chang Haonan''s face was serious and did not look like he was joking at all, he swallowed the words that came to his lips.
For a while, the progress of the test stopped.
Western in June.
Sunny day.
It’s afternoon again.
Even if the air conditioner is installed, the cabin will still be stuffy.
??Everyone was focused on the test just now, so they didn’t feel it, but this meeting made people a little upset.
Even Chang Haonan was inevitably affected by it.
In short, I couldn’t figure out what the problem was right away.
Mainly for wireless communications, there are too many influencing factors.
?Similar to aircraft design, humans only apply it based on engineering experience. In fact, there are still many principles that are not fully understood.
So sometimes we really can only consider the possibility that the machine soul is displeased...
“Reset the device and try again.”
Since his thinking was fruitless, Chang Haonan had no choice but to use his electronic product repair skills -
Restart.
?It was an accident just now that the guarantee was not complete.
?His instructions were quickly conveyed to each test vehicle via radio.
Technicians are already familiar with this kind of thing.
So, after a lot of trouble, the new control group and experimental group data were quickly measured.
The results are a bit fluctuating compared to just now.
But not much has changed.
? are 1.6 and 7.4 kilobytes/second respectively.
Still less than five times the result.
After careful calculation, it’s actually a bit worse than the first time…
Looking at the numbers on the screen in front of him, Chang Haonan felt the veins on his forehead throbbing.
He only used the system in the process of algorithm development, and this process ended long ago.
It is already in the engineering testing stage, and the system naturally does not include after-sales service.
??And he has no idea what the current problem is, nor does he meet the basic requirements for system startup...
"Mr. Chang, our next step..."
??Wu Wei mainly engages in ground single-hop communications, so in his heart he actually feels that this result is quite good, and there is absolutely no need to make things difficult for himself.
?But he definitely couldn''t say this directly, so he just asked Chang Haonan what he should do next with a little hesitation.
The latter looked at the time and knew that the test progress could not be stuck here forever.
The results are the same twice, indicating that the problem is reproducible.
It is not caused by unexpected interference factors.
On the other hand, since it can be improved by 5 times, it means that in principle, it is feasible to apply the combination of MRD and network coding to multi-hop communication.
As for why it is only five times, you can study it slowly after you go back.
“Let each car move its position and continue the test with a distance of 10 kilometers...”
?While giving the order, he jotted down the problem and several possible possibilities in the notebook next to him.
?Wu Wei next to him was relieved when he heard this instruction, and quickly directed the other three vehicles to enter the next test position.
Chang Haonan, on the other hand, sat beside him and continued to lose himself in deep thought.
The next step is a long wait...
He didn’t know how much time passed before he suddenly heard Wu Wei’s voice next to him again:
“Car No. 1, adjust the antenna angle and deflect it to the right by 5°30\''…”
Obviously, at this time, each communication vehicle has arrived at the scheduled second round position and is ready for final debugging before testing.
“Antenna angle…”
For a moment, a light flashed in Chang Haonan''s mind, as if he had grasped something important.
Logically speaking, due to the relatively poor directivity of wireless communications, it is almost impossible to adjust the antenna by a few degrees to have a huge impact on the communication effect.
The reason for adjustment is just to control variables and ensure the rigor of the test.
To a certain extent, it is the professional instinct of engineers.
?But now that I think about it carefully, it provides Chang Haonan with a new idea.
“Mr. Chang?”
??Wu Wei suddenly heard Chang Haonan repeat the words "antenna angle" just now. He thought there was something wrong with his operation steps, and quickly looked at the latter with questioning eyes. “It’s okay, keep testing!”
?Chang Haonan immediately cheered up again.
?His idea needs to be verified by the results of several subsequent tests.
…
Since this is already the third operation, the testing team is familiar with the entire process.
The efficiency is much faster than the previous two times.
At an interval of 10 kilometers, the speed of the control group was still the same.
1.5 kilobytes/second.
However, the situation of the experimental group has changed dramatically—
10.3 kilobytes/second.
When the result came out, Wu Wei''s eyes widened and he froze on the spot.
The quintessence of Chinese culture almost reached his lips, but he still forcefully took it back:
“Seven...seven times?”
Comparing with the test results at a distance of five kilometers, this time it seems that there is not much change, but it clearly shows one thing -
Chang Haonan was right just now.
Five times is indeed not the limit.
However, the more confusing thing is that the effect becomes better when the distance is farther...
You must know that the main distance for direct communication of the division communication vehicles developed by the 54th Institute is between 5 and 15 kilometers.
So he is and is most concerned about results within this range.
“Mr. Chang, do you need to repeat it again?”
?After a while, Wu Wei recovered from the shock.
?Chang Haonan raised his wrist and looked at his watch, and then calculated the time in his mind:
“Repeat it, move quickly, and then immediately switch to the 15km test...”
…
The following test results, from a qualitative perspective, are completely consistent with Chang Haonan’s expectations—
As the communication distance increases, the network throughput of the control group begins to decline significantly.
However, the experimental group has been rising against the trend.
By the time the four vehicles were 30 kilometers apart, the measured throughput data of vehicle No. 4 had reached 17.3 kilobytes/second.
In terms of absolute speed, of course it is still not fast.
It can even be said to be very slow.
However, compared with the control group, the improvement factor is basically close to the level when Chang Haonan conducted previous tests on the wired network.
19.7 times.
??Furthermore, after adopting the new technology, the network throughput measured after three rounds of relays (car 1 itself is also counted as one relay) is only about 15% lower than that of one round of relays.
The relay loss has been almost minimized!
?
Chang Haonan finally breathed a sigh of relief after his suspicion was completely confirmed.
As with most scientific work, the most grueling part is figuring out the problem from a jumble of clues.
Once this step is completed, the subsequent part of solving the problem is relatively easy.
At least on a psychological level.
After a slight pause, Chang Haonan gave new instructions over the radio:
“Attention all cars, today’s test is here first, prepare to close the team...”
These finishing tasks naturally have a dedicated person in charge, and there is no need for him or Wu Wei to handle them personally.
Therefore, the latter took advantage of this free moment to ask Chang Haonan the doubts he had just had:
“Mr. Chang, why is the transmission effect using network coding technology better after the communication distance is lengthened?”
“Because of the broadcast effect…”
Chang Haonan opened the door and left the car as he spoke, and then found a position upwind, preparing to blow in the refreshing evening breeze after the sun set.
?Although it smells a little like sand, it is much stronger than the stuffy heat inside the operating cabin.
This is good for inland areas at mid- and high latitudes.
No matter how hot it is at noon, the temperature will drop immediately as long as the sun is out.
“Broadcast effect?”
?Wu Wei thought for a while, but could not find this keyword in his brain.
"Ah...yes, I just came up with this term. It''s normal that you haven''t heard of it..."
Chang Haonan nodded and replied:
"That is to say, all the information in the physical layer of the wireless network is transmitted in the wireless medium through electromagnetic waves, so that multiple receiving nodes can simultaneously monitor the electromagnetic wave signal transmitted by one sending node. On the contrary, the information sent by multiple sending nodes can also Received simultaneously by a receiving end."
"This results in the packet data of adjacent hops causing "self-interference" to the data of this hop in the same business flow. Most wireless communication systems only allow one source to transmit information at the same time, or other sources transmit information. The superimposed signals are treated as interference and suppressed, which results in the actual throughput of the wireless multi-hop network being significantly lower than that of the wired network..."
“As the distance between several vehicles increases, the self-interference caused by the broadcast effect weakens, so the throughput increases.”
But this explanation did not completely eliminate Wu Wei’s confusion:
“But… the control group should also have the same effect?”
“Of course.”
?Chang Haonan put his hands behind his back, like a boss:
“However, the main factor affecting the network throughput of the control group is the transmission delay caused by repeated packet sending, and self-interference has little impact on it.”
“After applying network coding technology, the proportion of transmission delay gives way to processing delay, so the broadcast effect becomes more obvious..."
(End of this chapter)